Archive for the ‘Soapbox’ Category

Ming Campbell Resigns

Oct 15th, 2007

The resignation of Sir Menzies Campbell has been inevitable for some time now, given the Lib Dem’s recent poll performance. While as the Britain’s third party the Lib Dems have always attracted a smaller share of the media coverage, under Ming Campbell this presence has all but disappeared. This hasn’t been helped by his characterisation as an old man, half asleep and out of touch. While Kennedy may have been blighted with alcoholism and accusations thereof, and had a demeanour which spoke more of a cuddly uncle than a leader, he still manage to provide a better front for the party. Indeed, even Lib Dem supporters, such as myself, realise that the party isn’t striking for leadership yet, and in the unlikely even of obtaining it would be thrown into disarray. Indeed, the best we can ever hope for, come next election (whenever that may be) is probably some kind of coalition in the event of a hung Parliament, or second place should one of the other parties do something monumentally stupid.

Had Campbell not resigned he would have been forced out, with the resultant damage to the parties reputation sending its approval ratings still lower. At the time of writing information on BBC News is scarce, but I wouldn’t be surprised if Ming’s decision was partially influenced by some external pressure.

I also hope this next leadership election will be smoother than the previous. Infighting and bickering are not good for projecting an image of a united party.

I demand DOI’s!

Sep 6th, 2007

DOI stands for Digital Object Identifier, and in short is a permanent ‘address’ (like a URL) which will always point at a particular document. In particular DOI’s are used to make it easy to find academic papers, and saves one having to find the journal’s webpage, navigate to its archives, pick up the volume in question, and finally find the paper. More importantly unlike a URL you know that the DOI won’t change, and will still work when the journal decide to re-organise their system. For example, the DOI of Crick ans Watson’s DNA paper is doi:10.1038/171737a0.

As a scientist I have become used to reading heavily referenced papers and reviews. If someone says something they back it up, either by demonstrating it themselves, or otherwise pointing out where someone else has shown this. This will usually result in a huge list of references which, especially in review articles, can stretch on for an entire page or more. Typically a reference will provide the authors’ names, the year, the title of the paper (occasionally), the journal the paper appeared in (usually abbreviated), the volume, the issue (occasionally) and the page number. The DOI is also appearing in the bibliography with increasing regularity, and it certainly makes tracking down references much easier. But my issue isn’t with the academic journals so much as the newspapers.

Mainstream media coverage of science stories is often shockingly inaccurate and simplified to the point of inaccuracy. While a certain amount of this is understandable, your average science paper being outside the ken of most folks (and in some fields most scientists), it does leave me itching for more details. And here is the biggest problem… newspapers don’t reference. If you’re lucky you may get the journal, and then its a matter of clicking back through the past couple of issues, matching titles and abstracts with the story in the paper. However in many cases even this information is skipped, leaving me in the dark. (Of course, on some occasions the story in the paper reflects an as yet unpublished paper. Shockingly in some cases they haven’t even passed through peer review.)

Now I understand that in your average newspaper space is at a premium, they don’t want to spend column inches devoted to meticulously citing the paper they are reporting (Although frankly there is no excuse on the web). However a DOI is short, and provides all the information needed. It would allow for rapid finding of the paper in question, allowing people who are interested to find out the nitty-gritty. Furthermore, if a person happens across the article in a library archive in fifteen years time the DOI will still work.

Free Works

Aug 2nd, 2007

BBC News
The software giant said it would make ad-supported copies of the Works package available within “months”.

As a way of competing with OpenOffice.org I cannot help but see this as doomed to failiure. For one, slight performance hits excluded, OpenOffice.org is a superior package to Microsoft Works, having a feature set which for most people will be comparable to that of Office. Plus there is a significant difference between free and ad-supported, particularly in an office suite where you do not wish to be distracted by garish advertisments. While I assume MS will eschew the worst of the webs banner ads, and exclude pop-ups, the fact of the matter is that there is a fundamental discrepency between what ads are trying to achieve and was an interface is trying to achieve. One should be subtle and unobtrusive, the other is designed to draw your attention.

Works also lacks one of the major advantages Office has over OO.org, that of compatibility. While this has improved in recent years, and MS have at last made symbolic gestures towards open-standards, the fact of the matter remains that Works isn’t Office.

Now I’m sure there will be people who take advantage of this offer, but they will largely be existing Works users, who will either not have heard of OpenOffice.org, or don’t want to learn a new system. It will do little to draw the customers they are trying to retain.

Fopp Reprive

Jul 31st, 2007

Well it appears all is not lost and HMV have brought six Fopp stores, which they will continue to run independently under the Fopp brand. Strangely this covers almost every Fopp I’ve visited, Cambridge, Edinburgh and Glasgow. The Tottenham Court Road store is closing however, although another in London (Covent Garden) will be re-opening, but its in the same city so its close, even if London is a very big city.

I’m disappointed that it was HMV (Instead of an independent buyer) that had to rescue the store, but I hope they wont interfere too much, especially in terms of price and product catalogue.

[tags]Fopp, music, bankrupt, sales, retail, shops, HMV, reopen[/tags]
Guardian Unlimited: HMV to reopen six Fopp shops

MOO

Jul 19th, 2007

I’ve always been attracted by MOO, the flickr buisness card company, but have never had the need for buisness cards. While they are designed for personal use, I would feel slightly self concious handing out a mini-card, even if they are as sexy as the ones MOO make. I’m sure I could find some other use for them, but really it would just be me making an excuse for buying them, consumer whore that I am.

For those of you not in the know, MOO produce personalised buisness cards or notecards based on your flickr photos, although there is also the opportunity to upload your own images if you don’t have a flickr account. You can also use a few other accounts as a basis, including the possibility of images base on your second life avatar.

But recently MOO have launched stickers something which is a lot more fun, and more versitile. A little photo in the corner of the letter, or on a birthday card would be ideal. So now I have a little sticker booklet winging its way to me (postage is free during July).